3 Critical thinking and information
Learning Objectives
In this chapter you will learn
- How to evaluate information and why this is important
Being able to evaluate information is an important part of critical thinking. Critical thinking is an essential skill to develop and apply during your third-level education and will come in useful as a skill for employment and in general for making your way in a world awash with fake news, deep fakes, and misinformation. Scholarly information is not immune – some of the world’s most long-standing hoaxes are rooted in bad science, for example in poorly conducted research that has had to be retracted from scholarly journals, which can be seen on retractionwatch.
Evaluating Information
The following video explains the importance of ‘information literacy,’ which is critical thinking applied in particular to the world of information. It explains concepts such as ‘currency’ and ‘authority’ as part of a test that you can use to help think through the quality of information to evaluate it: the CRAAP test.
‘Scholarly’ information is information written by specialists of a particular field, usually someone holding a PhD in that field and who works at a third-level institution. In terms of the CRAAP test, scholarly information scores particularly high on ‘A’ for ‘Authority.’ This is the case not just because it is written by specialists, but because it usually goes through a process of what is called ‘peer-review.’ Peer-review refers to when where other specialists in the same field do a thorough check of a scholarly researchers work before it is then published as a journal article, book chapter, or occasionally other formats, as explained in the previous page.
The CRAAP Test
What is the CRAAP test? Developed by the Library at California State University, Chico, the CRAAP test is a handy checklist for critically evaluating web sources (or indeed ANY sources) for use in your assignments. The test provides a list of questions to ask yourself when deciding whether or not a source is reliable and credible enough to use in your assignment. CRAAP stands for Currency, Relevance, Authority, Accuracy, and Purpose. For more information, please see below.
The CRAAP Test
What is the CRAAP test? Developed by the Library at California State University, Chico, the CRAAP test is a handy checklist for critically evaluating web sources (or indeed ANY sources) for use in your assignments. The test provides a list of questions to ask yourself when deciding whether or not a source is reliable and credible enough to use in your assignment. CRAAP stands for Currency, Relevance, Authority, Accuracy, and Purpose. For more information, please see below.
Evaluating the Information You Find Using the CRAAP Test
Once you have found your information it is important to evaluate it so that you can keep what’s best. One way of doing this is by performing the CRAAP test on your sources.
Currency, Relevancy, Authority, Accuracy and Purpose
Asking the questions above about each website, document or piece of information that you find will help you decide which ones are relevant for your project.
Currency
When was it published? Is the information too old? Does it have a date on it? When was it last updated? How important is it that you have up-to-date information?
Relevancy
Does it fit your project? Will your project be stronger if you include this information?
Authority
Who has published or written the information? Do you trust them? Is it easy to find out anything about them? Who was it written for?
Accuracy
Is the information correct? Check with another source, if you are not sure to see if they say the same thing. Are the details correct?
Purpose
Why does the information exist? Is it trying to sell you something, persuade you or give you an opinion? Once you figure this out, you can then decide how to use the information that you have found.
REMEMBER: If you are not sure how to apply any part of the test, ask your librarian or teacher for help and support. Always evaluate the information you find.
There is lots of information available on the CRAAP test produced by universities and other libraries that can show you the test in action. You can find it by doing a simple search on the internet.
Content above is from https://www.teentech.com/wp-content/uploads/2016/01/evaluating_info.pdf
